Mark, By empirically I guess you mean judgementally? If so , no, I would base it on a sample test. I currently have a landscape pro re doing my front. I will ask to see his "guage" and advise. I guess you may have an instrument? The other treatment I finally came around to is iron sulfate for moss which is also a problem here. I have 2 ea 50 lb bags I am going to selectivey spread on the moss covered patches. I do not know if the many landscape people here do just use judgement on the liming. They may have worked out a rythm of every other year or even the persistence of the acid loving weeds-don't know.