Never had a Toro, they seem a little too proud of their mowers (price wise). I've had two Craftsman mowers over the years, both with Briggs and Stratton engines, and both were great. The last one I had was self propelled front wheel drive. It just wouldn't quit, it took a beating in the 12 years I had it and my only complaint about it was the front wheel drive was very hard to keep going straight in a bumpy yard. It was fine in the smooth yard of the house we lived in when I bought it. We moved to a house that had a bumpy yard, mostly due to tree roots, and it was a constant fight to keep the mower in line. After I broke my shoulder and had to cut our big yard with it one armed, fighting to keep it going straight, I decided to get a rider. I recently got rid of the Craftsman, which was still running strong, in favor of a lightweight push mower to use as a trim mower and on new grass that the rider might tear up. If you have a bumpy yard, you may consider a rear wheel drive model if you aren't already.