Export thread

I have just under 1 acre to cut, all flat with 1 tree. My wife cuts the grass and she wants a riging mower. She does NOT want a zero turn. I've been looking at the Husqvarna YT42XLS it's right at $2500.00. Is this the best mower for $2500.00 or is there a better one. From my research the Husqvarna seems to be very reliable. Not looking to spend more unless something is much better Thanks for your time and help..

I would take a look at the Simplicity rear engine rider for $1899. Very easy for your wife to control and with only 1 acre to cut the difference in time with a smaller deck won't be noticeable.

Using a mower that is too big for an area can actually cause you take more time to mow. Several years ago when our 42" craftsman was in about worn out, we tried replacing it with a 50" craftsman, and I could actually mower the yard faster with the 42", and I mow about 5 acres. I know mow with a 72" mower behind my compact tractor, and takes about the same time as it did with the 42". Would like to get a front deck grasshopper ZTR one of these days.

JET4 said:

I have just under 1 acre to cut, all flat with 1 tree. My wife cuts the grass and she wants a riging mower. She does NOT want a zero turn. I've been looking at the Husqvarna YT42XLS it's right at $2500.00. Is this the best mower for $2500.00 or is there a better one. From my research the Husqvarna seems to be very reliable. Not looking to spend more unless something is much better Thanks for your time and help..

Click to expand...

JET4,
All I can say is that if that Husqvarna YT42XLS had been available in 2006 when I bought my last lawn tractor(54" Craftsman YS4500-built by Husqvarna for Sears) before going Zero Turn last fall.....I would have bought that YT42XLS in a heartbeat. Go ahead and compare, but if you find another riding lawn mower with a lifetime warrantied fabricated deck, a Kawasaki engine and a locking differential hydro tranny(like that YT42XLS) BUY IT.....but I don't think youll find anything close to that Husqvarna and I believe it is well worth $2500 and recommend you pull the trigger(your wife will love it:0)

We will be buying from a dealer not the big box store. We did go to look at a couple of mowers at the big box store so my wife could just set on them tell we can get to the dealer.She likes the rear engine mower because it's little and cute she says. There is not a Simplicity dealer near me but there is a Snapper dealer near me. The Snapper RE 210 looks to be the same as the Simplicity. Is the Snapper a good mower. I have not ruled out the Husqvarna YT42XLS yet. It just looks like the rear engine mower would be easier for her to handle because it's smaller.

I am not a Snapper lover myself, but they do make a good mower in that size. Personally I think a rear engine would be easier for her to control. A plus would be if she picks it out and not you, better home life.

JET4 said:

We will be buying from a dealer not the big box store. We did go to look at a couple of mowers at the big box store so my wife could just set on them tell we can get to the dealer.She likes the rear engine mower because it's little and cute she says. There is not a Simplicity dealer near me but there is a Snapper dealer near me. The Snapper RE 210 looks to be the same as the Simplicity. Is the Snapper a good mower. I have not ruled out the Husqvarna YT42XLS yet. It just looks like the rear engine mower would be easier for her to handle because it's smaller.

Click to expand...

JET4,

User Rivets may be right about if the wife is happy, you'll be happy. Myself, with my BAD experience with a Briggs & Stratton 24hp INTEK, I wouldn't buy a Snapper simply because B & S builds them now. If I were you I would let my wife demo it and the Husqvarna, see if she prefers the Snapper lever blade engagement versus a PTO on the Husqvarna, the tiny cutting deck with no nose rollers on the Snapper not to mention I would tell my wife about the lifetime fabricated deck warranty on the Husqvarna(I'm sure your wife depends on you, like mine does, for the "techie" stuff). But just between you & I...if I had let my wife choose our first ZTR I would own a Lowes or Home Depot Cub Cadet RZT, a Toro TimeCutter or an Ariens Zoom(cheap Residential model lines) instead of my Gravely Commercial. Sorry, I'd rather be in the doghouse until she got over it:0)

You may not let your wife pick out your Z, but she is not using it. As I said, I am not a Snapper fan, but they do make a good mower. Does not make a difference who owns it, Snapper was using Briggs engines long before they were purchased by Briggs. My recommendation is based on what will work best for the original poster and is also based on my past experience of working on the different units for the passed forty years. If I based my recommendations on your standards, I would be telling him to look at the Kubota Kommander, which is far better than your Gravely, but does cost a bit more, as well as overkill.

We went to the big box store to look again and my wife sat on a zero turn and said she would test drive one. Like I said we will buy from a dealer, so my new question is, what is a good zero turn for $3000.00 or under. I'm not looking for a comercial mower as I will only be cutting the grass once a week for 30-45 minutes or so. I hope to buy a somewhat decent zero turn for $3000.00 or less. Thanks again for your time and help. Needs to be 42 or smaller

Jet I'll agree that if the wife is going to use the mower then she also needs to be happy. With that being said, I've just purchased a Husqvarna YTH24K48 Fast Tractor and I mowed for the third time yesterday and I love this mower. Now the option that you were looking at will be awesome with the Kawi under the hood and the locking diff is just a + imo. If a ZTR is what you choose then great but if your looking for a rider then I would consider the Husqvarna 100%.

I was looking at the Huslter Raptor 42 do you think that's a decent one Also looking at the Gravely ZT34, the perfect size to go through my gate with no trouble at all .42 would fit but be real tight.

JET4 said:

We went to the big box store to look again and my wife sat on a zero turn and said she would test drive one. Like I said we will buy from a dealer, so my new question is, what is a good zero turn for $3000.00 or under. I'm not looking for a comercial mower as I will only be cutting the grass once a week for 30-45 minutes or so. I hope to buy a somewhat decent zero turn for $3000.00 or less. Thanks again for your time and help. Needs to be 42 or smaller

Click to expand...

JET4,
The least expensive Residential zero turns that I would recommend would be the Toro Titan ZX or the Cub Cadet Z-Force you will find at dealers, but I think it will be difficult for you to find a ZTR smaller than a 48" deck and $3,000 for a "good quality" ZTR that will provide years of care-free service may be even more difficult. Just my opinion.

Rivets,
I don't want to sound confrontational regarding your Gravely/Kubota comment, but you may want to make sure you are comparing apples and apples, and have your facts straight. The 2013 model of my Gravely Pro-Turn 52" XDZ100 has a $7,499 MSRP and is a Commercial ZTR in every sense of the word(with a HydroGear ZT-3400 Commercial tranny, foldable ROPS and a Kawasaki FX series Commercial engine). The top Kubota Kommander model ZG127S(54") is a Residential ZTR(with ZT-3100 trannies and a one-piece ROPS) that runs approx. $5,900 and even the Kubota website "compares it" to a Toro Titan(another "Residential ZTR"). Not just bragging about my personal mower, but the Gravely Pro-Turn XDZ 100 and Kubota Kommander are in two distinctively different classes of ZTR's.

JET4 said:

I was looking at the Huslter Raptor 42 do you think that's a decent one Also looking at the Gravely ZT34, the perfect size to go through my gate with no trouble at all .42 would fit but be real tight.

Click to expand...

JET4,
Well, maybe I'm wrong about a ZTR in the $3,000 range as you have shown your diligence in searching for mowers!!! Indeed that Gravely ZT series is a very good entry-level Residential unit(the ZT HD series even "better"....close to Commercial quality) and the 42" ZT model at a MSRP of $3,199 would be a very good comparison to the 42" Hustler Raptor Residential model. Hustler "doesn't make no junk", but I will have to search as I seem to remember a thread on here where a Raptor purchaser was having some problems with his. Both of those brands are a good choice for you to look at(not just because I own a Gravely) and a distant third choice may be to compare those two to a similarly priced/size Husqvarna Residential ZTR. Husqvarna is my first choice for a lawn tractor but I'm not thoroughly convinced about their low-end ZTR's. Also, a consideration may be to look at Dixon ZTR's, which are also owned by Husqvarna. Another brand, if you have a nearby dealer would be Dixie Chopper(the Zee 2 line I think). There are so many good mowers out there today that you, like I, will probably have your head spinning after looking at a few of them and it won't be an easy decision which one to get(but you DO have your wife to help you out on that, mine didn't want to participate in the selection process:0) Good luck!!!

I ended up getting the Gravely ZT34. I wanted the Hustler Raptor 42, but it would not fit through my gate. I didn't want to go to thr trouble of making the gate bigger. The Gravely is a very nice mower for the money.

JET4 said:

I ended up getting the Gravely ZT34. I wanted the Hustler Raptor 42, but it would not fit through my gate. I didn't want to go to thr trouble of making the gate bigger. The Gravely is a very nice mower for the money.

Click to expand...

JET4,
Didn't mean to "influence you" with my Gravely banter:0)
But I know as well as anyone else on here you did like I did last September when I joined this forum when shopping for my first ZTR. Take in all the experiences and advice, look at some ZTR's, try to make sure it's apples-to-apples comparisons across brands, and then make a decision on what seems like the best fit for your needs. I've never owned a Gravely before this one which has 9.2 hours on it, but it does have a 1,000 hour/3Year Consumer Warranty, a 3Year Kawasaki warranty and a Lifetime frame/deck warranty. If I was wrong and it breaks down next weekend, I'll just let the dealer make it right as any purchaser of a new ZTR would no matter what the brand(that's why personally I never recommend going to Craigs List and spending several $1K on a used ZTR). I hope, by all means, you feel more comfortable with the dealer than you do with the new mower!!!!! That's what really matters. Personally I don't think you'll be dissapointed with a brand that's been building heavy duty farm equipment since 1916 and is now owned by Ariens(another reputable manufacturer). Let us know how you like it after you get some hours on it. BTW, I've got a next door neighbor that has an Ariens 46" Zoom ZTR with a Briggs and Stratton 16HP engine(one of the best B & S ever made) and the sealed EZT trannies. For over 16 years he's been making his yard look like a golf course(and making me green with envy) and now the shoe's on the other foot since I've got a brand new "Arien's big brother" Gravely Commercial and my yard has him thinking about getting a new Gravely:0)
P.S.
And post some pictures when you get it home.....we wanna see it!!!!

The dealer is the one of the reason I bought the Gravely. I went to the Hustler dealer and talked to him about two minutes, looked at my wife and said lets go. Rode to the Gravely dealer and started to talk to him and he was very nice. He said if something goes wrong with the mower he'll come pick it up take it to his shop and repair it and bring it back.

JET4 said:

The dealer is the one of the reason I bought the Gravely. I went to the Hustler dealer and talked to him about two minutes, looked at my wife and said lets go. Rode to the Gravely dealer and started to talk to him and he was very nice. He said if something goes wrong with the mower he'll come pick it up take it to his shop and repair it and bring it back.

Click to expand...

JET4,

I hear ya...my Hustler dealer "had an attitude" and would not "budge" from MSRP. I ended up getting a Commercial Gravely ZTR for a LOT less than he wanted for a high-end Residential Hustler:0(