Crabgrass is an amazing weed. If it didn't die in the winter, some say they would just cultivate it and let it be their lawn. In Hawaii, there is a variety of Zoysia that looks just like Crabgrass. Sometimes I wonder if it is and we're being told it is really Zoysia just to throw us off.
On your lawn in New England, seed has no doubt already dropped from this years plants and those seeds will be up in the Spring. While pre-emergent helps, I have found that the best way to rid your lawn of Crabgrass is to be diligent about Crabgrass killer during the growing season. I use Ortho "Weed-B-Gon Max plus Crabgrass Control" with very good results. You have to be patient. Crabgrass can take weeks to die from an application. During the heaviest growing times, I spray once a week. I only spray on active Crabgrass rather than the entire lawn. At the SAME TIME, I drop fresh GRASS SEED to fill in what is about to die from my spraying.
This method has worked wonders for me. My neighbor has let his entire yard go to Crab, and it invades my lawn something terrible. I spray on his side as I see the invading Crab inch toward me diligently to stop it dead. Literally. Then I reseed with grass seed.
Cutting your lawn high enough to CHOKE OUT emerging Crabgrass is important too. A healthy THICK lawn will keep all weeds at bay including Crabgrass. My neighbor scalps his lawn weekly in the Summer. Thus his horrible Crabgrass problem.
Good luck!