Fair enough. I'll keep a closer eye on that edge throughout the season. I think I was really hard on that set though, I can't remember them looking anywhere near that bad when I put them on (I alternate sets when sharpening).
I'm not concerned with a perfect mow. I don't have a 'lawn', just grass and weeds that grow. I mow them rather than spraying. As long as it's flat enough to walk on, that's all I care about. Though, I was thinking, do the mulching blades take more power due to chopping up the material more, rather than the high-lift just spitting it out the side? If so, high-lift is definitely for me.
Thanks for the replies so far guys.
To use my favourite quote, "the magic pudding is a fairy tale" so yes using mulching blades does come with a cost.
The blades work a lot harder and so does your mower.
So like using dull blades, mulchers will require slower mowing speeds.
You also have to cut higher so the fine "mulch" has some where to go other wise it will just make windrows & deposit big clumps of clippings that will not get blown around & distributed but stay as clumps on the grass.
On "lawns" this means cutting more often in peak growing season on paddocks not so important except a lot of weeds will seed between weekly mows and the seeds will happily germinate in the mulch layer so making weed control a lot harder.
They also deposit a lot of clippings with a lot more liberated acidic moisture on the underside of the deck so if not cleaned after each use will rot through the deck in a season or two.
The blades do a lot more work and wear a lot faster.
And any Gator style blade will break off a flute section and become unbalanced in no time flat.
The up side is gator blades are thicker & heavier so carry a lot more energy so don't bog down as much when they hit a clump of tufting type grass and if used as a replacement for regular blades with the discharge chute open work a lot better than most standard domestic blades.
Just a little note here, most domestic blades are about 1/2 the thickness & 2/3 the width of commercial blades.
Gators are made from the same material as commercial blades so they make a big difference to a smaller home owner ( domestic ) mower.
They make little difference when fitted on commercial mowers and in most cases wear our a lot faster but will throw the finner cuttings further so they disappear or bag better.