Many thanks for your comments. It's so cool when you can get on a site like this, get some insights, and save a bunch of $$. I wanted to get the mower going for the weekend so I stopped at tractor supply. They had a generic one that was 57" (specs say 57.5 or 57.75) and it says it's made with Kevlar. That 1/2 or 3/4 inches means a lot; I had a devil of a time pulling it over the last pulley. The tensioner is now doing it's job and hopefully will for a while. I was really taken back by my newfound knowledge about Troy-built and Cub really being MTDs but I shouldn't be surprised based on the price. I've been mowing over 2 acres with mine for 5 years so I guess I'm on borrowed time. So I'll just keep on truckin' as long as I can.
Thanks again everyone and have a great weekend!