I can't get a reference point to know how everything is set up. A further way picture of the mower might also be handy for a reference. Is it possible that the idler pulley gets pulled to the right and the blue line on the right gets put on the left side of the pulley. Also Bert, the flat on flat isn't absolute, MTD has a habit of using the inside of their 5/8 transmission belts on flat idler pulleys. Years ago all the variable drive mowers used a flat idler on the rear drive belt of their riders.